# No Series: Why Do I Need to Wear a Bicycle Helmet?

## Why Do I Need to Wear a Bicycle Helmet?

Lesson Objective: Create a key experience for a unit on Newtons Laws
Grade 8 / Science / Force & Motion
7 MIN

## Discussion and Supporting Materials

### Thought starters

1. Why does Mr. Rettberg have students repeat and revisit the same experience multiple times?
2. How do students incorporate new vocabulary to discuss difficult concepts?
3. What role does prediction play at different points in the lesson?
4. How does it deepen learning?

Are there any student pages for this demonstration?

Recommended (0)
This is a great lesson. The environment, the preparation, the movie-like anticipation created and execution were superb
Recommended (0)
The anticipation built while waiting for that egg to finally drop was epic!! I felt like a kid in your class. How cool and meaningful to watch??!! I like how you encouraged the students to use the vocabulary gained from each successive lesson in their discussions with peers What you said about science word walls or word walls in general is true. If the words have no meaning outside of the classroom, they're just words they'll use in a certain class, and that class only. Thanks fr letting us view you and your scholars in action!!
Recommended (0)
Valerie, would you be able to share the lesson plans from HICE? When I searched online all the links were broken and it seems like the initiative at U Michigan is no longer in operation. Thanks! Ruby
Recommended (0)
p 48 in the unit as the four "questions": Questions 1. Describe what happened as the egg and the cart traveled down the ramp. Explain why this occurred. 2. Describe what happened to the egg and the cart when they reached the barrier. Explain why this occurred. 3. Describe what happened during the collision of the egg with the tabletop. Explain why this occurred. 4. Describe how a helmet would change the events of the collision. ￼ ￼2 additional questions that can be used in this first learning set to help students relate the egg and cart to their personal experiences. 5. Describe how this demonstration is similar to your story. 6. Describe how this demonstration is different from your story. p 51: Questions for Inquiry. Give students a few minutes to think about things they know and how they know them. 1. What do we know that will help to answer the driving question? 2. How do we know this thing, what is our evidence? p52: Ask students to think of questions to contribute to the question board. They should make sure their questions meet two criteria. 1. Is the question related to motion or collisions? 2. Will the answer to this question help us to answer the driving question?
Recommended (8)

### Transcripts

• Great Lesson Ideas: Why Do I Need to Wear a Bicycle Helmet?
with Mike Rettberg

[01:00:11;14]
Mike: My name is

Great Lesson Ideas: Why Do I Need to Wear a Bicycle Helmet?
with Mike Rettberg

[01:00:11;14]
Mike: My name is Mike Rettberg. I teach 8th grade science. And, this unit will help you answer the question "Why do I need to wear a helmet when I ride my bike?"

"All right. Here we go!"

We're exploring the ideas of force and motion. So the purpose of the demonstration is to create a key experience. Something that we can talk about, um, in subsequent lessons, and just keep referring to. So right now, we're about half way through the unit, exploring the model of an egg for your head, and talking about collisions to apply Newton's laws, which we've been learning about, to this demonstration.

"3"

So this is a unit that takes about six weeks, start to finish. The demonstration is repeated four times throughout the unit. The first time is just as an introduction. So, let's watch the egg collide with the barrier, and then write. So, initially their explanations are very simple, kind of what you'd expect from anybody.

Then as we learn concepts, like acceleration, inertia, force, motion, Newton's first, second, and third laws, they'll have to re-write an explanation.

"So what we're going to do is, we're gonna look back at the work that you did a couple of weeks ago, when we were just starting the unit, thinking about "Why do I need to wear a helmet when I ride my bike?" What I want you to do is re-read what you wrote last time, and then you're gonna re-write. You're gonna make a new prediction. What are we gonna see today? When you are writing today, I want you to think about our Word Wall. I want you to think about our vocabulary words. Could you use the word acceleration? Could you use balanced force? Can you talk about momentum?"

And, so we have, you know, have the students predict, and then write.

"All right. Please turn and share what you've written with somebody in your group."

Then you also saw every time after they write, they had to turn and talk, and share what they wrote with their neighbor, so they're just practicing using the words and getting comfortable.

Student: "The acceleration of the egg was faster because it had more mass."

Mike: If you want kids to acquire new vocabulary, you have to teach it in a variety of ways. Like, if we don't discuss the words, if we don't practice using them, they, they remain, you know, words that are up on the wall that a student might think "OK. I'm gonna use this in science class."

Student: "Force equals mass times acceleration."

Mike: "OK. Can somebody explain that for me in their own words. What does that mean? What was Isaac Newton telling us?"

The valuable part, the learning part of it, is when we then discuss and talk about it.

Student: "The momentum of the cart..."

Student: "will accelerate as it went down."

Student: "Gravity will work as an outside force."

Student: "Newton's third law of motion explains"

Student: "when the egg and the cart hit the barrier"

Student: "the inertia of the barrier will cause the cart to bounce back, and"

Mike: Vocabulary kind of floats on a sea of talk. And, so what I'm really trying to do is just get them to use the words as much as possible.

"Let's take a look at question number 1. So, what we're going to do is..."

So today's lesson, the first question that the students investigate is the idea of "What happens as the egg and cart travel down the ramp?"

Student: "The cart will increase acceleration as it travels down the ramp."

Mike: It's really based on Newton's first law of motion, the idea that objects in motion stay in motion. We talk about acceleration, things like that.

"Both the cart and the egg will what?"

Student: "Build up momentum"

Mike: "OK. I think that's a pretty good prediction. I would like to hear two of our main vocabulary words incorporated here that I'm not hearing so far. What are the two main vocabulary words?"

All: "Force. Motion."

Mike: "Do those belong in here somewhere?"

All: "Yes."

Mike: "All right. So, somebody tell me where we can incorporate those words into our prediction."

Student: "The pull of the gravity."

Mike: "Yep. So, we could add 'gravity is pulling on both the egg and cart.' "

I'm trying to get the rest of the class to comment on what's good in here. Who can tell what's missing in here? Who wants to change something in here? And, so we actually end up going through, like, just changing some words, maybe adding something new, so that we develop as a class. OK, here's what a good prediction, um, would look like.

The second question shifts and asks them what happens just at the moment of that collision between the cart and the barrier. This is more of a demontration really of Newton's third law of motion that

Student: "Every, every action has a reaction."

Mike: "And what about that reaction needs to be.."

Student: "Opposite."

Mike: "and..."

Student: "Equal."

Mike: "Equal and opposite reaction. So we're expecting that the cart is going to... Richard."

Richard: "The cart will bounce back, then go back, hit the barrier again, and stop."'

Mike: "OK. So, we're expecting the cart is going to bounce, and then stop."

And, then Newton's first law, which tells us the egg, since it's not being stopped, should continue in motion.

Student: "The momentum the cart had transferred to the egg. Since the barrier did not hit the egg, it was still in motion, and the extra momentum caused the egg to have more force as it flew off the cart.

Mike: "That sounded really good."

The third question is asking 'What happens just at the moment that the egg collides with the floor?'

Student: "It flew forward, and gravity's force pushed it down, forcing the egg to collide against the floor."

Mike: "And why is it gonna crack? It's just gonna crack because of force, right? Because the force of the, the eggshell, which is actually pushing out, is holding the egg together, is not gonna be as strong as the force of the floor.

"Last words on the egg?"

Student: "Sucker!"

Mike: Then it's time to do the demonstration.

"Here's the egg; he looks completely terrified."

The joy factor is really important. If they kids are not having fun, it doesn't matter what you're talking about. They're not gonna pay attention.

"All right. Here we go. All right. Ready? 1...2...3…"

It's also fun. I mean it's just purely fun.

All: "OOHH!!" (Laughter)

Mike: "Brutal! Brutal! That one was perfect!"

I make sure that the safety part of it is also, it's hyped.

"Serious brain injuries..."

Student: "Is he alive?"

Mike: "Is he alive? I doubt it."

When we talk about why do you need to wear a helmet, the kids, they get it.

"Like, pretty massive cracks. You got some good ooze coming out of it there."

A decision like wearing a bicycle helmet, uh, is a really good one.

### School Details

1430 Scott Street
San Francisco CA 94115
Population: 374

Data Provided By:

### Teachers

Mike Rettberg
Science / 8 / Teacher

UNCUT CLASSROOMS
|
52 MIN

### Discovering the Properties of Quadrilaterals (Uncut)

Discovering the Properties of Quadrilaterals (Uncut)

UNCUT CLASSROOMS
|
29 MIN

### Heterogeneous Literature Circles (Uncut)

Heterogeneous Literature Circles (Uncut)

TCH Special
|
42 MIN

### Hybrid Best Practices

Webinar / Distance Learning / Engagement

TCH Special
|
58 MIN

### Creating Community Connections

Webinar / Class Culture / Coaching

TCHERS' VOICE

Class Culture

TCHERS' VOICE

Lesson Planning

TCHERS' VOICE

New Teachers

TCHERS' VOICE

Engagement